New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 1
New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 2
New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 3
New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 4
New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 5
New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr - Image 6

Photo 1 / 6

New York City Little Italy Mafia History Tour and Dinner 1.5 hr

TourTruth score 7.2 out of 10

AverageTop 48% in New York City

146 reviews · Rated on 1 provider · How we score

  • New York City
  • 1 hr 30 min
  • Updated November 4, 2026

Walk Little Italy, hear stories of John Gotti and the Gambino family, then enjoy a traditional Italian Christmas dinner with live entertainment.

About this tour

Explore Little Italy after dark, where festive streets and storied landmarks set the scene for a walk through New York’s Italian-American past. This New York City Little Italy mafia history tour and dinner pairs neighborhood culture with tales of notorious mob figures.

Follow your guide past landmarks such as the Church of San Gennaro and along Mulberry Street. Hear stories about John Gotti, the Gambino family, and the neighborhood’s connections to organized crime, while learning about the traditions that shaped Little Italy. The guided walk lasts about 1.5 hours and offers a lively look at the area’s history and character.

After the walk, settle in for a traditional Italian Christmas dinner at Il Cortile, with live entertainment. Vegetarian options are available upon request; alcoholic drinks can be purchased separately. Arrive 15 minutes early, wear comfortable shoes, and dress warmly for the outdoor portion. The event runs rain or shine.

Choose this New York City Little Italy mafia history tour and dinner for an evening that brings local stories, historic streets, and Italian dining together. Book your spot and experience a memorable side of the neighborhood.

Highlights

  • Stroll festive Little Italy streets with a local guide
  • Hear stories about John Gotti and the Gambino family
  • Admire landmarks such as the Church of San Gennaro
  • Enjoy a traditional Italian dinner with live entertainment
  • Discover Italian-American culture and neighborhood history

What's included

Included

  • Guided walking tour of Little Italy
  • Traditional Italian Christmas dinner at Il Cortile
  • Live entertainment during dinner
  • Discounts on future visits and nearby shops

Not included

  • Transportation to and from the event
  • Alcoholic beverages, available for purchase
  • Gratuities

Ratings on each provider

The ratings and review counts each booking site shows for this tour.

Important information

  • Arrive 15 minutes early for check-in
  • Dress warmly and wear comfortable shoes
  • The event proceeds rain or shine
  • Vegetarian options are available upon request
  • Meeting point: 120 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10013

How this score is calculated

This score is based on one provider. GetYourGuide rates it 4.61 from 146 reviews. We place that rating among all GetYourGuide ratings and weight it by its review count. If the tour is found on another provider later, both ratings are combined.

How the score works and rating distribution in New York City
  • Each provider rating is turned into a percentile: the share of that provider's ratings it beats, weighted by review counts.
  • Listings on different providers are combined in proportion to their review counts.
  • Tours with few reviews are pulled toward the average until more reviews come in, so a handful of perfect reviews can't top the list.
  • The result is shown from 0 to 10: this tour scores 7.2. Top 48% in New York City means it ranks in the top 48% of tours in New York City by this score.

Provider rating distribution in New York City

How many tours in New York City have a provider rating at or below each value. The dashed line is this tour.

  • GetYourGuide
  • Viator

from $200

on GetYourGuide

Check availability