New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 1
New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 2
New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 3
New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 4
New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 5
New York Murder Mystery Quest - Image 6

Photo 1 / 6

New York Murder Mystery Quest

Not rated yet

Rated on 1 provider · Why

  • New York City
  • 1 hr
  • Updated November 2, 2026

Solve riddles and crack codes on a self-guided murder mystery quest through New York’s historic South Street Seaport.

About this tour

Follow a trail of riddles through New York’s historic South Street Seaport and uncover the story of a captain lost to time. This self-guided murder mystery quest brings the cobblestone streets to life with clues, codes, and a centuries-old secret.

Begin at McNally Jackson Books, then use the free ClueKeeper app to guide your investigation. The route covers about half a mile and takes around 60 minutes, though the story describes an experience lasting 1–2 hours. Three quest sheets are emailed for you to print; if you cannot print them, you can use a notebook, but the puzzles will be more challenging. The quest ends near a spot where you can buy food and drinks.

Gather your fellow puzzle fans and set out to solve the mystery at your own pace. New York Murder Mystery Quest offers an engaging way to explore the Seaport while following a ghostly tale.

Highlights

  • Unravel the mystery of a missing captain
  • Solve riddles and crack codes along historic South Street Seaport
  • Explore cobblestone streets on a quest spanning about half a mile

What's included

Included

  • Three printed quest sheets emailed for you to print

Not included

  • Food and drinks at the finish

Ratings on each provider

The ratings and review counts each booking site shows for this tour.

Important information

  • Self-guided experience; no guide will meet you
  • Use the free ClueKeeper app and three printed sheets; a notebook can be used instead, but puzzles will be more challenging
  • Infants and small children can ride in a stroller
  • Service animals are allowed
Show 3 more
  • Public transportation is available nearby
  • Suitable for all fitness levels
  • No minimum age of 21

How this score is calculated

This tour has no TourTruth score yet: Viator doesn't show a usable rating for it. It gets a score as soon as a provider lists one.

How the score works
  • Each provider rating is turned into a percentile: the share of that provider's ratings it beats, weighted by review counts.
  • Listings on different providers are combined in proportion to their review counts.
  • Tours with few reviews are pulled toward the average until more reviews come in, so a handful of perfect reviews can't top the list.
  • The result is shown from 0 to 10. Tours without a usable provider rating are not scored.

More City & Sightseeing Tours in New York City

from $50

on Viator

Check availability